MLB PICKS

MLB Picks for May 9

ParlayLab's methodology engine grades the Saturday, May 9, 2026 MLB slate against the market. 15 games with 5 HIGH-confidence picks — moneyline, run line, total, and player props. The full pick selections are available with a free 7-day Pro trial.

Los Angeles Angels at Toronto Blue Jays

3:07 PM ET

Angels (5-15) visit the Blue Jays (10-12). Probable starters: J. Kochanowicz (4.55) for Angels, T. Yesavage (2.25) for Blue Jays. Dome — no weather impact.

Pitchers

LAAJ. Kochanowicz (4.55)

TORT. Yesavage (2.25)

FanDuel lines

MLLAA +154 · TOR -184

RL+1.5

TotalO/U 8.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

Athletics at Baltimore Orioles

4:05 PM ET

Athletics (11-10) visit the Orioles (7-13). Probable starters: A. Civale (3.31) for Athletics, S. Baz (4.87) for Orioles. Weather at first pitch: 72°F.

Pitchers

ATHA. Civale (3.31)

BALS. Baz (4.87)

FanDuel lines

MLATH +102 · BAL -120

RL-1.5

TotalO/U 9.5

ParlayLab pick

MED

HIGH edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

Houston Astros at Cincinnati Reds

4:10 PM ET

Astros (7-12) visit the Reds (10-11). Probable starters: S. Arrighetti (1.32) for Astros, C. Burns (1.83) for Reds. Weather at first pitch: 72°F.

Pitchers

HOUS. Arrighetti (1.32)

CINC. Burns (1.83)

FanDuel lines

MLHOU +136 · CIN -162

RL+1.5

TotalO/U 8.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

Tampa Bay Rays at Boston Red Sox

4:10 PM ET

Rays (16-6) visit the Red Sox (11-11). Probable starters: N. Martinez (1.51) for Rays, P. Tolle (2.27) for Red Sox. Weather at first pitch: 72°F.

Pitchers

TBN. Martinez (1.51)

BOSP. Tolle (2.27)

FanDuel lines

MLTB +122 · BOS -144

RL+1.5

TotalO/U 7.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

Chicago Cubs at Texas Rangers

7:05 PM ET

Cubs (18-3) visit the Rangers (8-12). Probable starters: E. Cabrera (4.06) for Cubs, J. Leiter (4.61) for Rangers. Dome — no weather impact.

Pitchers

CHCE. Cabrera (4.06)

TEXJ. Leiter (4.61)

FanDuel lines

MLCHC -130 · TEX +110

RL-1.5

TotalO/U 8.5

ParlayLab pick

MED

HIGH edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

Seattle Mariners at Chicago White Sox

7:10 PM ET

Mariners (11-9) visit the White Sox (11-9). Probable starters: L. Castillo (6.41) for Mariners, A. Kay (3.96) for White Sox. Weather at first pitch: 71°F.

Pitchers

SEAL. Castillo (6.41)

CWSA. Kay (3.96)

FanDuel lines

MLSEA -134 · CWS +114

RL-1.5

TotalO/U 9.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

New York Yankees at Milwaukee Brewers

7:10 PM ET

Yankees (16-5) visit the Brewers (12-8). Probable starters: C. Schlittler (1.50) for Yankees, K. Harrison (1.77) for Brewers. Dome — no weather impact.

Pitchers

NYYC. Schlittler (1.50)

MILK. Harrison (1.77)

FanDuel lines

MLNYY -134 · MIL +114

RL-1.5

TotalO/U 7.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

New York Mets at AZ

7:15 PM ET

Mets (8-11) visit the AZ (6-12). Probable starters: C. Holmes (1.86) for Mets, M. Kelly (5.25) for AZ. Weather at first pitch: 55°F.

Pitchers

NYMC. Holmes (1.86)

AZM. Kelly (5.25)

FanDuel lines

MLNYM -108 · AZ -108

RL-1.5

TotalO/U 9.5

ParlayLab pick

LOW

MED edge

ML / RL / O-U projection

Unlock with Pro

3 qualifying picks across moneyline, run line, and totals.

How ParlayLab grades the slate

Our methodology engine projects each MLB game using a market-blended model that combines team-level offense, starting-pitcher form, ballpark factors, weather (wind direction relative to center field, temperature, precipitation), bullpen fatigue, and Statcast contact quality. The engine outputs a moneyline, run-line, and total projection for every matchup and grades each pick HIGH / MED / LOW confidence based on the edge versus the FanDuel line.

Player props go through a separate Poisson projection layer per stat — hits, home runs, total bases, RBIs, runs scored, hits+runs+RBIs, and pitcher strikeouts. Each prop projection accounts for the batter-vs-pitcher history, recent rolling form, opposing pitcher ERA / WHIP / K%, ballpark-by-handedness factors, and weather. Props with strong projection-vs-line edges show up bright green; weak ones drop to orange or red.

Free users see the top picks for each market per slate plus the per-game matchup context shown above. The full pick selections, every prop on the board, the prop filter builder, and the full Game Detail + Player Detail breakdowns unlock with a Pro trial. No card charged for the first 7 days.